🍁 civid v1

🌐 Models of Government

How is power organized in a country? Who is head of state versus head of government? Which offices are elected, appointed, or inherited? This is a living, comparative atlas β€” explore and contrast the systems of the world, aligned on a shared spine so equivalent roles line up across very different designs. Starting with three; built to scale to every country.

Structural comparison

Each column is a country; each row a universal tier of authority. A country that lacks a tier shows an empty slot β€” that absence is itself the lesson (e.g. the US has no monarch; its President fills both head-of-state and head-of-government). Node colour = how the office is filled; ring thickness = real power.

Head of StateSymbolic sovereignty / ceremonial…Head of GovernmentLeads the executive and sets the …Upper HouseSecond chamber: review, revision,…Lower HousePrimary elected legislature; usua…Sub-nationalProvinces / states / regions and …LocalMunicipal councils, mayors, localβ€¦πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ Canadaβ—‹The Crown (King)●Prime Minister◐Senate●House of Commons●Provinces & Territories◐Municipal Councils & MayorsπŸ‡¬πŸ‡§ United Kingdomβ—‹The Crown (King)●Prime Minister◐House of Lords●House of Commons◐Devolved Legislatures◐Local CouncilsπŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ United States●President●President●Senate●House of Representatives●States◐Counties, Cities & Towns
Selection: Directly elected Indirectly elected Appointed Hereditary Mixed
Real power:β—‹ ceremonial◐ significant● dominant(ring thickness)

Click any node to inspect that office β€” its role, how it’s filled, its term, and a sourced fact.

πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦

Canada

Federal parliamentary constitutional monarchy

Constitutional monarchyParliamentaryFederalWestminster
πŸ‡¬πŸ‡§

United Kingdom

Unitary parliamentary constitutional monarchy

Constitutional monarchyParliamentaryUnitary (devolved)Westminster
πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ

United States

Federal presidential constitutional republic

RepublicPresidentialFederalSeparation of powers

Compare by role

The same canonical role, side by side. Hyphen means the country has no equivalent office.

TierπŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ CanadaπŸ‡¬πŸ‡§ United KingdomπŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ United States
Head of StateThe Crown (King)
Monarch / Head of State
Hereditary
The Crown (King)
Monarch / Head of State
Hereditary
President
Head of State
Indirectly elected
Head of GovernmentPrime Minister
Head of Government
Indirectly elected
Prime Minister
Head of Government
Indirectly elected
President
Head of Government
Indirectly elected
Upper HouseSenate
Upper chamber
Appointed Β· 105 seats
House of Lords
Upper chamber
Mixed Β· 800 seats
Senate
Upper chamber
Directly elected Β· 100 seats
Lower HouseHouse of Commons
Lower chamber (MPs)
Directly elected Β· 343 seats
House of Commons
Lower chamber (MPs)
Directly elected Β· 650 seats
House of Representatives
Lower chamber
Directly elected Β· 435 seats
Sub-nationalProvinces & Territories
Provincial legislatures (MLA/MPP/MNA)
Directly elected
Devolved Legislatures
Scotland / Wales / NI assemblies
Directly elected
States
State legislatures & governors
Directly elected
LocalMunicipal Councils & Mayors
Local government
Directly elected
Local Councils
Local government
Directly elected
Counties, Cities & Towns
Local government
Directly elected

πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ Canada

Federal parliamentary constitutional monarchy

Canada is a constitutional monarchy with a Westminster-style parliament. The monarch (shared with the UK) is head of state, represented in Canada by the Governor General. Real executive power rests with the Prime Minister, who leads the party commanding confidence in the elected House of Commons. Power is divided federally between Ottawa and the provinces.

Head of State
The Crown (King)
Monarch / Head of State Β· Life (hereditary)

Same monarch as the UK; almost entirely ceremonial in Canada.

source β†—
Head of Government
Prime Minister
Head of Government Β· While holding Commons confidence

Not directly elected as PM; leads the party that commands the House.

source β†—
Upper House
Senate
Upper chamber Β· Until age 75

Appointed by the GG on the PM’s advice; reviews legislation ("sober second thought").

source β†—
Lower House
House of Commons
Lower chamber (MPs) Β· Up to 5 years

Elected by first-past-the-post; the government must hold its confidence.

source β†—
Sub-national
Provinces & Territories
Provincial legislatures (MLA/MPP/MNA) Β· Up to 5 years

10 provinces + 3 territories; constitutionally sovereign in their domains (health, education).

source β†—
Local
Municipal Councils & Mayors
Local government Β· Typically 4 years

Created by provinces ("creatures of the province"); powers delegated, not constitutional.

source β†—

πŸ‡¬πŸ‡§ United Kingdom

Unitary parliamentary constitutional monarchy

The UK is the original Westminster system: a constitutional monarchy where the King is head of state and the Prime Minister, leader of the Commons majority, is head of government. Unlike Canada it is unitary, not federal β€” but it has devolved legislatures (Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland). Its upper house, the Lords, is unelected (largely appointed, with some remaining hereditary peers).

Head of State
The Crown (King)
Monarch / Head of State Β· Life (hereditary)

Source of the Westminster model Canada inherited; ceremonial in practice.

source β†—
Head of Government
Prime Minister
Head of Government Β· While holding Commons confidence

Leader of the party commanding the Commons; appointed by the monarch.

source β†—
Upper House
House of Lords
Upper chamber Β· Mostly life; ~92 hereditary

Unelected: life peers (appointed), bishops, and remaining hereditary peers. Can delay, not block.

source β†—
Lower House
House of Commons
Lower chamber (MPs) Β· Up to 5 years

Elected by first-past-the-post; supreme chamber (Parliament Acts).

source β†—
Sub-national
Devolved Legislatures
Scotland / Wales / NI assemblies Β· Up to 5 years

Powers DEVOLVED (granted, reversible) β€” not federal/sovereign like Canadian provinces.

source β†—
Local
Local Councils
Local government Β· Typically 4 years

Mix of unitary, county, district authorities; some directly elected mayors.

source β†—

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ United States

Federal presidential constitutional republic

The US is a presidential federal republic β€” a sharp contrast to Westminster. There is no monarch: the President is BOTH head of state and head of government, directly (via the Electoral College) and separately elected from the legislature. Congress (Senate + House) is a co-equal branch, not subordinate to the executive. Power is split by strict separation of powers and federalism between Washington and the states.

Head of State
President
Head of State Β· 4 years (max 2 terms)

No monarch β€” the President is also head of state. Chosen via the Electoral College.

source β†—
Head of Government
President
Head of Government Β· 4 years (max 2 terms)

Separately elected from Congress β€” not dependent on legislative confidence.

source β†—
Upper House
Senate
Upper chamber Β· 6 years (staggered)

Directly elected (since 1913); 2 per state regardless of population. Powerful & co-equal.

source β†—
Lower House
House of Representatives
Lower chamber Β· 2 years

Directly elected, apportioned by population. Originates revenue bills.

source β†—
Sub-national
States
State legislatures & governors Β· Varies (2–4 years)

50 states with reserved powers (10th Amendment); own constitutions, mostly bicameral.

source β†—
Local
Counties, Cities & Towns
Local government Β· Varies

Highly varied; many directly elected mayors, councils, sheriffs, school boards.

source β†—